The Scoop Deck

For hospital ships, deployments bring hope and partnering — but will they survive budget cuts?

The hospital ship Mercy got a unique recognition last month when the National Conflict Resolution Center gave the ship its National Peacemaker Award for bringing medical and humanitarian aid overseas, including annual “Pacific Partnership” missions in 2008, 2010 and 2012. It was the first time the San Diego-based center gave the award to a “thing” and not a person. “The amount of humanitarian aid that everybody on the ship provides – really as a team – they really reach out around the world,” Lisa Cole-Jones, the center’s fund development program manager, told us. The ship’s crew was elated. “The more we read (about the award), the more we felt it did fit with the work that we have done over the years,” said Capt. Tim Hinman, who commanded Mercy’s Military Treatment Facility before handing it to his executive officer, Capt. William B. Cogar. “It was very good recognition.”

Call it the Peacemaker. The hospital ship Mercy returned to San Diego after its 2008 “Pacific Partnership” mission to Southeast Asia. (Gidget Fuentes/Navy Times)

Mercy’s award came in the shadow of the Navy’s decision last month to cancel several ship deployments due to federal budget cuts, including that of its sister ship, hospital ship Comfort.  The Navy in late March announced the Norfolk, Va.-based Comfort would not conduct this year’s “Continuing Promise,” the annual humanitarian mission to Central and South America that’s akin to the Pacific Fleet’s “Pacific Partnership.” This year’s scheduled mission would have started April 9 and taken Comfort to eight countries this spring and summer. Like prior missions, sailors and medical teams with the embarked Military Treatment Facility and other embedded nongovernmental aid organizations would have provided medical, dental and veterinarian care to local residents – surgeries and preventative medicine are among the sought-out needs during such missions – and assist with civic construction projects.

In recent years, the Navy has been deploying its two hospital ships annually, alternating with gray hulls, for the popular humanitarian missions the military sees as spreading the “global force for good” and helping allies and partners in need. Medical care is seen as the great uniter, and the Navy’s ability to step in and provide help, whether in larger humanitarian assistance missions or smaller civic action projects done by smaller forces or ships’ crews during community-relations events during liberty port calls, are seen to benefit the larger strategic picture of engagement, presence and, frankly, spreading goodwill. That help is particularly welcomed in the more remote places of the South Pacific and South Asia, where storms, tsunamis and other natural disasters have damaged infrastructure, particularly in coastal areas.

But will budget cuts, and the expected shrinking defense budget, put a big dent in the mission? The Navy has not yet announced this year’s “Pacific Partnership,” originally scheduled for the summer with dock landing ship Pearl Harbor tentatively carrying out the mission to Oceania. But those who have deployed for these missions say there is great value to the nation. “If you think about the missions that we did, Pacific Partnership starts with partnering, and we bring together people from different organizational backgrounds,” said Hinman, noting in last year’s mission, he deployed with and hosted people from 26 nongovernmental organizations and 13 partner nations, all who worked and lived aboard the ship with his crew in the joint mission. Mercy had about 1,300 people on ship at any time during that recent deployment. “You form a hospital, and go to these countries and form collegial and professional relationships,” he said, adding, “I was overwhelmed in many cases with the reception that we got.”

When they left the ship, Mercy’s teams worked in remote areas, including parts of Indonesia with few modern conveniences and they sometimes encountered locals who rarely if ever see Westerners, let alone a big white ship. “To see it in person makes a big impression. It can have a potential of sending a message of support and of hope,” Hinman said. At one point, Mercy ventured north to Vietnam, a notable stop for many veterans aboard the ship. “I almost went there 40 years ago, potentially as a combatant,” said Cogar, who had enlisted as a hospital corpsman in 1972. This time, though, Mercy brought along a high-tech laser treatment system that now is being shared to help with critical care.

Sailors and civilians “man the rails” for Mercy’s return from its 2008 deployment.

The humanitarian missions remain popular with medical personnel as well as NGOs. “People are standing in line to come aboard this vessel,” Hinman said. “People really want to be here. It’s really positive and exciting.” Life aboard the ship, an 894-foot converted oil tanker, can get a little crowded, particularly to those unfamiliar with living at sea, working seven days a week in often hot and humid environments. “It’s not a traditional gray hull ship,” Hinman said, noting civilian mariners keep the ship running.  “Teamwork is important. Safety is important,” said Command Master Chief (FMF/SW) Thomas Twigg, the MTF’s senior enlisted adviser. “There’s a lot of sailors that have never been out on gray hulls.” And like many civilians, soldiers and airmen find time on Mercy is unlike any deployment they’ve done. “It can be a little bit of a shock in the tight spaces in berthing,” Twigg said.

Cogar added the lack of private berthing on the ship is a surprise to some civilians whose only time at sea is on a cruise ship. “It’s not a luxury liner. It is a mission-driven ship,” he said. Yet for those who volunteer to go, that remains the biggest draw. “Everybody played a part,” Hinman added. “We needed to be a cohesive team,” he said. “We are dealing with people’s lives.”

Comments

  1. For hospital ships, deployments bring hope and partnering — but will they … | xpaintme1325w Says:
    April 6th, 2013 at 3:50 pm

    [...] For hospital ships, deployments bring hope and partnering — but will they … The hospital ship Mercy got a unique recognition last month when the National Conflict Resolution Center gave the ship its National Peacemaker Award for bringing medical and humanitarian aid overseas, including annual “Pacific Partnership” missions in … Read more on Military Times (blog) [...]